Candidates for Deletion

FishTank·8/13/2015 in General Discussion

<p>This standing thread should be for articles marked with the {{Delete}} tag or Flags. If you disagree with why an article should be deleted, please comment here. </p>

(Edited by FishTank)

American Horror Story Wiki Candidates for deletion

Zakulla·8/16/2021

V Nixie should stay because she is credited and has multiple roles and likely will have more in the future.

FishTank·8/16/2021

@Zakulla I respectfully disagree. Multiple roles as a stunt actor does not qualify as significant. Even a single episode appearance (like Aaron Tveit's role as Jay in "Feral") does not qualify them as a significant AHS actor needing a page.

Aaron TveitAmerican Horror Story Wiki

Zakulla·8/18/2021

@FishTank I understand your point but didnt Aaron Tviet play someone in the first episodes of American Horror Stories?

Glee.heartxx·7/20/2022

Can you not delete Bobby Richter ll from American Horror Story season 9. he needs a page because he's a special part to the season so please keep him in and DO NOT delete him.

Miru Shiroi·7/19/2023

The "Hellmouth" section should NOT be deleted" It is an integral part of the AHS lore and its elements are present in basically every season

FishTank·7/19/2023

@Miru Shiroi Where and what is the "Hellmouth"? If you mean the Murder House, there is already an article for it.

Murder House (location)American Horror Story Wiki

PalZer0·10/22/2023

Any particular reason why Hell is marked for deletion?

HellAmerican Horror Story Wiki

(Edited by PalZer0)

FishTank·10/22/2023

@PalZer0 Yes. Because it's not a single location. As the article makes clear, it's an individual state of mind. There's no one Hell.

PalZer0·10/22/2023

@FishTank There's also a Hellmouth at the Hotel Cortez (as referenced in Apocalypse) so this concept, IMO, is significant in that it spans multiple seasons. You could also argue that Camp Redwood from 1984 is also a Hellmouth (though it isn't explicitly mentioned as such) given both the very similar behaviour of the ghosts there and the fact that Satan also made his presence felt there through Richard Ramirez.

Hotel CortezAmerican Horror Story Wiki

PalZer0·10/27/2023

@FishTank My take is that "Hell" in this instance is like a hotel/apartment complex with infinite capacity and each "guest"/resident has their own room/apartment (with some sharing a room/apartment).

For what it's worth, I don't see anything wrong with the article itself that would merit deletion. It's consistent with the style guide for location articles and its subject is a significant part of the series. That there's no one Hell doesn't seem to me to be a valid reason to delete the article (and, indeed, my point above makes an attempt to address that).

(Edited by PalZer0)

What do you think?