I think if it is in a more vintage style, it'll feel more like old AHS. 60's would be so cool, theres enough modern settings I think.

@Weenispeenis321 I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s the 2000s. There’s a nostalgia thing going with the 2000s right. A lot of movies have come out in the last couple years set during the early aughts.

Yeah,Too Full of memories

I think that it could be interesting to see some horror stories in the 2000s.