American Horror Story Wiki
American Horror Story Wiki

"Blue Moon" is the ninth episode of Double Feature. It premiered October 13, 2021.


An unexpected visitor arrives at the White House and reveals the details of the horrific plan. [1]



Eisenhower is having difficulty with the treaty trading the torture of Americans for technology. Subject 1, inhabiting Mamie, continues to threaten the well-being for the First Lady.

Three years later, 298 more incursions have been observed with no communication from the aliens. One materializes on the North Lawn in a beam of light. The new visitor, dressed in a black suit, introduces himself as Valiant Thor, dispatches guards and agents with ease on his way to the Oval Office. He is the android liaison tasked with the creating of the hybrid species. He presents to them a handheld computer, which strongly resembles an original iPod, but with a touchscreen.

Mamie is trying to follow up her legacy of promoting adult birthday parties by starting a tradition of decorating for Halloween.

Eisenhower hears screams trough the White House ventilation system, tracking them to the basement, where to find a concealed door in the service tunnels. A panel on the door activates on touch, then recognizes his handprint and the door opens to an elevator taking him 20 stories down. Valiant Thor says that the President's visit was not expected for several weeks yet. The android claims the tunnels in which experiments are being conducted were built years before, in preparation for nuclear "exchange," but the President was unaware of them. Several specimens of hybrid, in various ratio of human/alien aspects, are suspended in fluid in clear glass vessels in the lab. Valiant Thor explains that the extraterrestrials are convinced Eisenhower, and humanity by extension, would cancel the treaty if humans saw their true forms. Valiant Thor intimates that the extraterrestrials will take what they want by force rather than deal with the Russians.

Mamie is undeterred when her husband brings concerns to her. She suggests that, as "Val" mentioned they were getting crowded under the White House, space be made at the facility in Nevada she heard talked about. Soon after, he secretly deeds the facility to the aliens by executive order.

Hearing an unfamiliar moaning noise in the residence, Eisenhower finds Mamie astride Val, sexually engaged. The sight causes him to faint, clutching his chest. When he awakes, she is unapologetic, calling Thor both a machine and a visiting dignitary. She considers it revenge for an affair he had during the war. Dejected, the President walks away questioning if he even knows his wife anymore.

Sometime in 1962, Marilyn Monroe is on a film reel talking about the alien treaty. Nixon and Eisenhower review the film at FBI Headquarters. FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover obtained the film in his archive investigating Communist sympathizers. Eisenhower says that no one will believe her, and that her vices can be exploited. Monroe soon finds suited men in her home who stage her fatal pill overdose. A drunken Nixon calls President Kennedy with his condolences, but with advice that Kennedy not disclose alien secrets to his lovers in the future.

A year later, a motorcade unloads Nixon, Eisenhower, and now President Lyndon B. Johnson at Area 51. Thor greets the men and introduces himself to the new President. The men are shown a warehouse full of pods holding preserved hybrids.

Present Day

Troy Lord is about to give birth, and Theta enters his mind to calm and still him. She opens his abdomen with a laser scalpel. An attendant pulls a sac from Troy's body, then cuts it open to reveal a hybrid baby. The baby is strong and has some obvious alien physical characteristics. It apparently has some unspecified, but unacceptable defect, althought the closest hybridization attempt yet. Theta instructs that it should be stored. The newborn's throat is cut and it is placed in tank of preservation fluid. Troy gasps and strains trying to get to the baby, but is quickly subdued by Theta.

One week later, he rejoins his friends in the dining room. He explains that he delivered the baby, to which he was psychically connected, before it was slaughtered. Cal comforts his boyfriend, as they lament the experience. Calico overhears their talks of an escape attempt and tries to dissuade them from that notion.

Since 1969 she has produced two or three offspring a year, and in that time no one has escaped Area 51. She takes them on a tour of the "moon landing" set, telling them of how the historic event was staged: Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin, who were supposed to be in orbit, were in a bar where she worked as a prostitute. She plied them with liquor to get them talking about how they improvised the famous quotes. During the night she spent with the astronauts, suited men abducted her. She awoke implanted with a nearly-mature fetus and began wandering the facility, eventually finding the moon set, overseen by Director Stanley Kubrick. The landing hoax was meant as propaganda to guide the public into believing rapid technological advancement was plausible.

Back in present day, She thanks them for their time and leaves, with the group finding peace "on the moon."

Later, Cal thinks it is time to deliver. He is not ready for them to take his offspring, and Troy offers to buy some time. Troy leads him to the moon landing set, and Troy believes he can cut the baby out of his boyfriend himself. Using a metal scalpel, he cuts Cal open and pulls out the writhing pod. The hybrid is alive, and they initially are in awe of her. When her hips emerge from the pod, her squid-like tentacles suddenly wrap around her father's head and the toothed mouth underneath chews into his face.

Featured Characters[]

Lyndon B. Johnson[]

Lyndon B. Johnson was the 36th President of the United States, taking office after the murder of President Kennedy.

Neil Armstrong[]

Neil Armstrong part of the Apollo 11 Mission. He was believed to have been the first person on the moon.

Buzz Aldrin[]

Buzz Aldrin (born Edwin Eugene Aldrin Jr.) was part of the Apollo 11 Mission.

Stanley Kubrick[]

Stanley Kubrick was the director responsible for the filming of the Apollo 11 fake spaceflight.


  • Lily Rabe ("Amelia Earhart") and Rebecca Dayan ("Maria Wycoff") are credited but do not appear.
  • A "Blue Moon" is an astronomical phenomenon; the third of four full moons in a season. The title of the episode may also be a pun to the "Blood Moon" (October full moon) from Roanoke.
  • Similarily to the previous two episodes, the years in the past are in black and white.

Cultural References[]

Raised Questions[]

  • How many times did Mamie have sex with Valiant Thor?
  • Are those failed products really dangerous?
  • Are future US presidents aware of the mass human experimentation facilitated by the aliens?