Tensions in the house start to build between the living while the dead begin to make their mark.
In the the remote production trailer, Sidney Aaron James and his unnamed cameraman watch monitor what's on the camera, Matt is attacking Dominic. He thinks audiences will be satisfied to see this. Then, Sidney's assistant bring food for them. The cameraman inadvertently sees Rory being stabbed by Miranda and Bridget Jane, and then they disappear instantaneously and caused the interference in the camera. He tells this to Sidney but he dosen't see anything in the carmera. As Sidney is ready to rewind, he and his cameraman hear something outside. It was Sidney's assistan being killed by Agnes, who is completely consumed by her role as The Butcher. Then she kills Sidney and his cameraman.
In the house, Dominic discovers a pool of blood whre Rory was last seen, but Audrey brushes it off as Rory and Sidney pranking them while Rory has left to take the role working with Brad Pitt. Tensions continue to rise as Matt, Shelby and Dominic argue about Shelby's infidelity. Lee and Monet go back and forth about her alcoholism. The fighting is interrupted when Agnes appears and chops Shelby's shoulder.
Dominic stops Agnes, but after aiding Shelby, Agnes is gone. With no functioning phones, Lee, Audrey, and Monet go into the woods to find help. On the way to find help, Audrey and Monet begin to encounter Edward Philippe Mott that frighten them. Lee shots him multiple times but it didn't work as he is a ghost. They arrive at the remote production trailer amd Agnes attempts to kill them but is shot by Lee. The three womans run without stop and halfway they see who are holding the torch. Rory's corpse is discovered, having been gutted and suspended from a tree, Audrey is very sad to see that. Eventually, the three woman are kidnapped by the Polk family via electric shock, and are taken back to their farm, where the Polks proceed to cut Lee's leg off and feed it to Audrey and Monet.
Meanwhile, inside the house, Dominic and Shelby come across Matt having sex with Scáthach. Matt admits that he came back to the house for Scáthach, causing Shelby to murder him in a violent rage, bashing his head on the floor with a crowbar. Then, Agnes lights a fire outside the house, demanding satisfaction from the occupants of it. Just then, The real Thomasin White and her ghostly mob surround Agnes. Ignoring her patronizing pleas of adoration, Thomasin kills Agnes by cleaving Agnes' head without saying anything.
- Audrey Tindall: "Oh, leave me alone! I'm not American, I'm not used to all this carnage!"
- Agnes Mary Winstead: "Am an theine far gach uile chnoic. Am an sleagh catha"
Cast and characters
- Sarah Paulson as Audrey Tindall
- Lily Rabe as Shelby Miller
- André Holland as Matt Miller
- Adina Porter as Lee Harris
- Cheyenne Jackson as Sidney Aaron James
- Evan Peters as Rory Monahan
- Angela Bassett as Monet Tumusiime
- Cuba Gooding, Jr. as Dominic Banks
- Kathy Bates as Agnes Mary Winstead
- Finn Wittrock as Jether Polk
- Robin Weigert as Mama Polk
- Frederick Koehler as Lot Polk
- Frank Collison as Ishmael Polk
- This marks the first episode of Return to Roanoke to have characters that did not die from the ghosts or supernatural occurrences i.e. Alissa, Sidney, and Matt.
- Will Lee escape?
- Who killed Mason?