- 2011 (Six Months Ago)
As the Harmons move in, Nora is distraught that someone has changed her house. She collapses into a chair and starts to weep for her baby as a man comforts her. The mystery man approaches the house trash can and retrieves the rubber suit that Ben had thrown away. The door to Ben and Vivien's bedroom opens, and Vivien is inside rubbing lotion on her legs. Rubber Man and Vivien have sex. Afterward, Ben returns to the bedroom, passing Rubber man on the stairs, and both Vivien and Ben in a daze tell each other they love the other. In the bathroom, Rubber Man takes off the suit. Tate is underneath. His motivation is to get Vivien pregnant so that Nora can have a baby.
Vivien, Moira, and Marcy are talking in the kitchen. Vivien expresses that she is not crazy and that Nora was really in the house. Moira and Marcy try to dissuade her from this notion and explain it rationally, but Vivien is convinced someone is trying to make her feel like she's crazy. Marcy tells Vivien that her cousin Helen became paranoid when she was pregnant. Marcy leaves to speak to Mr. Escandarian.
Chad feels like he's going crazy. He is dining with his friend Peggy and seeks her advice. He says that Patrick has been distant lately and explains that the renovations to the house have put them under a lot of stress. He states that every time he brings up the subject of having a baby, Patrick changes the subject. Peggy asks him if maybe he's just overreacting. Chad then confides to Peggy that he has found out that Patrick is having an online affair in a BDSM chat room. She advises him to take charge and to "spice things up a bit". As a result, Chad goes out and buys the rubber suit.
He later tries to seduce Patrick while wearing the suit, but an annoyed Patrick tells him to take it off. Chad calls him an asshole and confronts him about the BDSM chatroom and says he thought Patrick wanted to start a family in the house. Patrick says he didn't want to spend his life decorating houses. Angry, Chad tells him to leave, and live with "junglejim4322" in a motel room. Patrick tells him that Chad won't have anything to threaten him with much longer, as he has seen their bills and knows they are going to lose the house. He leaves the room and Chad sits down on the bed, sobbing.
Hayden confronts Nora who's crying and tells her how it's annoying her, then begins to comfort her. She explains that there are other ghosts trapped in the house. Hayden tells Nora about her angry feelings. Nora refuses to believe she's dead, but Hayden shows her the bullet hole in the back of Nora's head. Hayden and Nora relate over their lost children, and Hayden suggests they take Vivien's babies because she can't "raise children in the loony bin".
Vivien is washing up in the bathroom. She tells herself she is just tired and proceeds to walk into her bedroom. A sound is heard from the hall, and Vivien leaves her room. The red ball rolls down the hall and Vivien picks it up, asking if anyone is there. The lights blow out and Hayden, behind Vivien, laughs and shatters a vase. Vivien picks up a candlestick to use as a weapon. Another vase falls and a dresser rushes towards Vivien, forcing her to retreat to the bathroom, where she sees the Rubber Man mask on the sink.
Tate dons the Rubber Man suit, before starting to drown Chad in the bobbing apple barrel. Patrick, dressed as a cowboy, comes upon the Rubber Man and his murdered lover. Tate/Rubber Man proceeds to grab Patrick, hurling him against the table bludgeoning him before grabbing a fireplace rod to beat him. He then proceeds to murder Patrick by piercing his rectum with the hooked rod. Nora is in the basement looking over the gunshot wound on Patrick's head, Tate comes behind her, comforting her and telling her he knows she has suffered a long time, and that he killed them because they decided not to have a baby. He ensures her that he will help her get a baby.
Violet, confronting her fears, goes to the basement to play with Beauregard. Ben finds her downstairs and asks who she is talking to. Violet lies and says "No one". The two go up to Ben's office, where they have a father-daughter talk. Ben tells Violet he has been informed that she has not been at the school for the last two weeks and asks her why she's missing classes. Violet argues that it's boring and they bully her and then points out that his wife is acting weird as well. Ben tries to psychoanalyze her, but Violet snaps at him, telling him it is his fault.
The scene moves to Moira and Vivien, who are talking. Vivien tells Moira she has an explanation for "all the crazy stuff that's happening". Moira pours her some tea and comforts Vivien. She tells her about a book called "The Yellow Wallpaper", about a woman who is locked in the attic for a slight hysterical tendency. Being trapped there, day after day, the woman begins to hallucinate that there are women trapped in the pattern of the wallpaper and scrapes it all off. When her husband returns, he finds her whispering "I finally got out of here" to the wallpaper. Moira continues to tell Vivien that men will always find reasons to lock women away. She tells Vivien that she is not crazy, and the things in the house are really happening and that the house is possessed. She finally tells Vivien that she should leave the house.
Vivien wakes Violet and tells her they're leaving the house. As they walk away, Tate watches from the front porch, before catching Violet's eyes, seemingly begging her not to go with his eyes. They get in the car, but the ghosts of Fiona and Dallas are in the back seat, and they scare them from the car. They run back into the house.
Ben confronts Vivien for trying to take Violet away from him. Vivien tells him the home invaders were here, but Ben doesn't believe her, as the police found no evidence. They argue. Vivien reassures him that Violet saw them too.
Violet gives Tate her virginity. She describes the experience of sex as "intense". Tate agrees. Tate reassures Violet that he'll always be with her, and Violet asks if the others will be too. Tate tells her that they can't hurt her. Violet asks him if the home invaders are dead, too. He tells her they are only trying to scare her and that she can't tell anyone, because they'll think she's crazy and send her away. Ben calls Violet down.
Ben and Vivien continue arguing about leaving the house, Vivien's mental health and Hayden. Vivien throws the rubber mask at Ben, asking if he wore it on Hayden too, but he denies ever wearing it. Violet lies about what she saw the previous night, saying she confirmed her mother's story to the police because it was what her mother wanted.
Hayden tells Tate that Vivien has booked their plane tickets and that he knows what he has to do. Tate acknowledges she's right, and she tries to seduce him to get him excited before he rapes Vivien. Tate refuses her advances, saying that he is in love. She tells him what he is about to will be difficult, and he has to prepare himself.
Vivien confronts Marcy about Joe, but as they are arguing, Vivien fakes sickness, and Marcy rushes to get her a drink of water. Vivien steals Marcy's gun from her purse before she returns, and then tells her she isn't feeling well and that she's going to lay down. Marcy then leaves.
Vivien goes to bed, checking around her room before she sleeps, and finds herself seeing the Rubber Man in the dark. She gets back up to investigate. The Rubber Man passes behind her, and then he grabs her. Vivien screams, and he releases her, and she stumbles back to the bed. She grabs Marcy's gun as someone comes in. Believing it to the Rubber Man, she immediately shoots him. It is Ben.
Luke confronts Ben about Vivien's "psychotic break", believing he has ulterior motives. Ben demands he leave.
Vivien is suffering from hallucinations of the Rubber Man attacking and Hayden trying to take her babies. Ben and Luke hold her down and try to calm her as she insists her rapist and Hayden are in the house. Violet ushers in two police officers who take her to a psych ward.
Ben leaves to go to the hospital with Vivien, leaving Tate and Violet alone in the house. Tate assures Violet that he will be there for her.
Tate is in the process of dragging the bodies into the basement when Moira interrupts him. Chad is still alive and tries to reach for Patrick. Moira gives Tate their gun, and he stages the scene to make it look like a murder/suicide by shooting Patrick several times before making Chad hold the gun and shoot himself in the heart.
PeggyPeggy is a supportive friend of Chad's and a lesbian. She is portrayed by Kathleen Rose Perkins.
GaryGary is a British salesclerk at the S&M shop where Chad buys the rubber suit. He is portrayed by Richard Short.
- Moira O'Hara
Haven’t you read "The Yellow Wallpaper" by Charlotte Perkins Gilman?
- Vivien Harmon
- Moira O'Hara
Her husband, a doctor, locks her away in the upstairs bedroom to recuperate from a slight hysterical tendency. Staring at the yellow wallpaper day after day, she begins to hallucinate that there are women trapped in the pattern. Half mad, she scrapes off the wallpaper to set the women free. When her husband finally unlocks the door he finds her circling the room, touching the wallpaper, whispering 'I finally got out of here.'
- Patrick (to Chad wearing the rubber suit)
Decided to go as sausage for Halloween this year? [...] Chad, depressing sex is even more depressing when you try so hard. [...] Take it off, so that we can watch Rachel Zoe without me worrying about you passing out. [...] And for the record, I like leather, not latex.
- [Hayden meets Tate in the basement]
Look at Little Lord Fauntleroy. Writing sorrowful sonnets in your head to that little Nightingale bitch?
- Hayden (mocking)
Who gives a shit!? You're like a girl sulking down here in the basement instead of doing something about what's really bothering you.
- [Hayden speaks to Tate about getting rid of Vivien by raping her]
You know what you have to do?
Yeah, I do. I just have to prepare myself. It's not fun.
Do you wanna fool around while you work your way up to it? Come on!
I'm not into it!
What is it about being dead that makes me so horny?!
Quit it! I'm in love.
You are pathetic. [...] Better locate your balls before you go in there, that bitch is tough!
Did it hurt? The first time usually does.
No, it was intense.
For me too.
You really are here, aren’t you?
Of course. I’ll always be here… If that’s what you want…
And they’ll always be here too, won’t they? The… whatever, others.
They can’t hurt us, Violet. They’re just trying to scare you.
I wish I could tell my mom that.
You can't! You can't Violet! If you tell anyone what we know, they'll say you're crazy. They'll lock you up. They'll try to take you away from here! We'd never see each other again!
Cast and characters
- Connie Britton as Vivien Harmon
- Dylan McDermott as Ben Harmon
- Taissa Farmiga as Violet Harmon
- Evan Peters as Tate Langdon
- Frances Conroy as Moira O'Hara
- Kate Mara as Hayden McClaine
- Lily Rabe as Nora Montgomery
- Christine Estabrook as Marcy
- Zachary Quinto as Chad Warwick
- Teddy Sears as Patrick
- Morris Chestnut as Luke
- Azura Skye as Fiona
- Kyle Davis as Dallas
- Denis O'Hare (Larry Harvey) and Jessica Lange (Constance Langdon) are credited but do not appear. This is the only episode from the first four seasons not to feature Lange.
- All fetish gear was from the LA latex fetish specialist store "Syren". 
- The screen names of Patrick and his "master" in the BDSM yahoo chat are "Hardlovejunky656" and "JungleJim4322", respectively.
- This episode can be considered a "Villain Episode", which either tells an episode's story from its antagonist's point of view or focuses on the season's main antagonist rather than the protagonists. In this case: Tate, Nora, Chad, and Hayden.
- Preview in slow motion
- Chad Visits an S&M Store (currently broken)
- Hayden & Nora discuss abducting Vivien's twins
- Vivien tells Marcy and Moira that she saw a ghost, Nora.
- ↑ "Ode to a Nightingale"
- ↑ Explanation of the poem
- ↑ Stack, Tim, "Rubber Man revealed!", EW, 23 Nov 2011